Compromising Prudence (The Mad Hatterlys)

Compromising Prudence (The Mad Hatterlys #1)

By: Marguerite Butler


Aurora Regency (Musa Publishing) 2010

An historical romance fiction review

(Review of The Mad Hatterlys #2 at


When Prudence decides to take control of her own destiny her defiant spirit quickly enmeshes her with strange men, strange places, and more alcohol than is advisable to imbibe.  When her path crosses with bird-loving Charles Hatterly, Prudence finds that compromising may be the key to achieving her new, independent life.  Charles Hatterly is far from used to compromising, but finds himself doing so more and more when it comes to Prudence.  Will their arrangement rescue them both from their family’s censure?  Or will it just lead them into imprudent decisions and compromised positions?

Compromising Prudence is a tuxedo strawberry of a book!  It’s sweet, fresh, and charming, with an orderly outside to complement its natural inner deliciousness.  The rules of society surround Butler’s story, but always come second to the main characters’ personalities.  Prudence is wonderfully strong-willed without becoming the stereotypical headstrong heroine.  Likewise, Charles’ ability to adapt his thinking gives him more maturity than the usual bewildered bachelor.  The emotions of these characters, particularly Prudence, read as very organic and relatable.  Their relationship dynamic is delightful because once they’ve met it arises from simple experience of each other rather than relying on shocking events or societal values.  The lack of melodrama doesn’t dull Butler’s book, but adds extra lightness, making this a quick, easy read for whiling away plane time, car trips, rainy days, or tea time.  But it’s the inherent likability of Charles and Prudence that drives this romance to the level of sweetness that turns Compromising Prudence from plain fruit into tuxedo strawberries.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: